Semantic commenting, academic?

See if you recognize this from anywhere.
John makes a point J and firmly strands behind it.  Jessica strongly disagrees and articulates reason JJ. Steve sees the logic in JJ and supports Jessica in opposition of J. Johns point J is facing stiff opposition.  Mary takes part in the discussion and  strongly supports Johns point J. Mary argues for J with reason JM and against JJ with answer JJM. Apparently Marys points hit the mark because when Stefan and Rebecka join the discussion they both take Marys view and strongly support J, JM and oppose JJ. Stefan articulates his reasoning in JS which seals the argument by offering a solution to the issue Jessica raised.

Know of anything that works like this? Where? 

It's not a graph, it's a network. It's similar to reviews since an argument is a rating and also a comment in some cases.

Imagine each step in the process sending you an alert,  like a chat with a link. Would this be useful in proofing ideas and reaching decisions? 

I'm thinking this exchange is qualitatively different from what we have today, and could have a positive impact in many ways.

The box in corner

That things that pops up in the corner, with the tweet in it, it's an experiment of mine. It works on touch screen as well by the way.

The idea if pretty simplistic. Drag it up by the great area to vote on it. Higher is better.

You get to engage with tweets from the site owner in a fun way while giving feedback.

Think there's something here?

CONNECT SITES together through the wibe hash tag..

What would you like it to be?